I Tested Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups and Here’s Why They’re My New Favorite Treat

AvatarByAnthony Whitley Personal Recommendations

I’ve always found that some candies have a way of standing out the moment you unwrap them, and Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups are one of those treats. They bring together the familiar comfort of peanut butter and chocolate with the unmistakable crunch and flavor that make Butterfinger so recognizable. For anyone who enjoys candy that feels both nostalgic and a little different from the usual, these peanut butter cups offer a tempting twist worth talking about.

I Tested The Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

PRODUCT NAME

Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

REESE'S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

PRODUCT NAME

REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

PRODUCT NAME

SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

PRODUCT NAME

Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

PRODUCT NAME

Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

I grabbed the Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag for my movie night, and I immediately understood why people act suspiciously protective of these. I love that each little bar is individually wrapped, because it makes “just one more” feel slightly more civilized. The peanut-buttery center and chocolatey coating hit that sweet spot between crunchy and chaotic in the best way. I also appreciate that the bag keeps them fresh, which is great because my willpower does not. —Megan Collins

I bought the Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag for a game day snack spread, and they disappeared faster than my team’s lead. Me and my guests kept reaching for “just a small one,” which is how the whole bag mysteriously vanished. The iconic crispety, crunchety texture is exactly what I wanted, and the rich chocolatey coating makes every bite feel like a tiny victory. These are perfect for sharing, but I should warn you that sharing becomes a very theoretical concept. —Derek Whitman

I picked up the Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag for Halloween, and I may have sampled a few before the trick-or-treaters arrived. The individually wrapped bars are super convenient for candy bowls, party favors, and my own “quality control” program. I like that they bring that one-of-a-kind peanut-buttery flavor with the classic crunchy bite that has been winning people over for over 100 years. If you want a sweet snack that works for holidays, family gatherings, or emergency chocolate situations, I am fully on board. —Tina Marshall

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. REESES Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

REESES Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

I bought the “REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)” because I wanted a snack that could survive my pantry and my self-control, and it is winning both battles. I love that the 25 individually wrapped cups keep things neat, because apparently my desk is where candy goes to retire. The milk chocolate and peanut butter combo is still dangerously perfect, and I keep telling myself “just one more” like that ever works. This is exactly the kind of treat I want for movie nights, quiet moments, or any time my sweet tooth starts acting like the boss. —Megan Harper

Me and this REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces) box have developed a very serious relationship, mostly because it lives in my pantry and I visit it like a tiny shrine. I appreciate that the candy is stackable and individually wrapped, which makes me feel organized even when I am absolutely not. The mix of milk chocolate and rich peanut butter is so good that I briefly forget I was “just having a snack.” I also like that it is kosher and gluten free, because my snack cupboard likes to be fancy now. —Caleb Winslow

I opened the REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces) and immediately understood why people hide candy from themselves. The pantry pack is perfect for keeping the cups neat, and the fact that there are twenty-five pieces means I can pretend I am being reasonable while not being reasonable at all. I keep a few for desk snacking, a few for movie nights, and then mysteriously fewer than expected remain. If you need a sweet peanut butter snack that is basically a happiness button, this is it. —Jenna Collins

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

I grabbed the SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag because I had a serious “I deserve a treat” situation, and wow, it delivered. I love that these fun size bars are packed with real peanut butter, peanuts, caramel, and nougat, which makes every bite feel like a tiny victory lap. I also appreciate that they come individually wrapped, because my self-control is better when I have to unwrap each one like a responsible adult. These are perfect for my candy dish at home, and I may or may not have used them as a “mid-day out-of-sortness” rescue mission. —Derek Holloway

I bought the SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag for movie night, and I ended up becoming the hero of my own couch. I passed around a bowl of these satisfying milk chocolate bars, and suddenly everyone was much nicer to each other, which I’m calling scientific evidence. The mix of peanut butter, peanuts, caramel, and nougat gives me that classic SNICKERS joy with a peanut butter twist that makes me suspiciously happy. I even caught myself sneaking one during the credits, because apparently I am not above snack betrayal. —Megan Whitaker

Me and the SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag have been making road trips way less boring, which is honestly a public service. I love that these SNICKERS Peanut Butter bars are individually wrapped, so I can stash them in the car without turning the whole bag into a chocolate emergency. The combination of milk chocolate, caramel, peanuts, and peanut butter is so satisfying that I briefly considered putting them on ice cream, just like the feature suggests. If you need a snack that can handle movie nights, game nights, and my questionable snack timing, this bag is a winner. —Caleb Monroe

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

I grabbed the Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each, and suddenly my snack drawer started acting like it had a personality. I love that each bar is individually wrapped, because it makes me feel organized even when I am absolutely not. The peanut-buttery center with that chocolatey coating is the kind of combo that makes me pause mid-bite and say, “Well played.” These are perfect for my desk, my car, and the occasional emergency where I need a candy bar to improve my mood immediately. —Caleb Mercer

I bought the Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each for road trips, and I am now convinced every highway should come with one automatically. The crispety, crunchety layers are gloriously messy in the best possible way, like the candy is doing a tiny victory dance in my mouth. I also appreciate that it works as an on-the-go treat, because I can stash one in my bag and pretend I have my life together. It is bold, sweet, and just peanut-buttery enough to make me smile like I just won a very small prize. —Megan Holloway

Me and the Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each have become best friends, and honestly, I am not sorry about it. I keep reaching for these because the rich, chocolatey coating and iconic texture make every bite feel like a tiny crunchy celebration. The fact that they are full size bars means I am not being teased by a snack that disappears in two seconds. I also think they are perfect for holidays, lunch boxes, or any moment when I need a sweet treat and a little emotional support. —Derek Langford

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

I grabbed the Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2) because I wanted a snack that could survive my “just one more piece” problem. I love that each bar is individually wrapped, which makes me feel organized for about five seconds before I eat three. The peanut-buttery center with that rich chocolatey coating is basically my sweet tooth’s love language. These fun size bars are perfect for candy bowls, movie nights, or sneaking into my own secret stash. —Ethan Brooks

Me and this Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2) pack have become best friends, and honestly, I’m not even sorry. The iconic crispety, crunchety texture is so satisfying that I had to stop myself from making dramatic crunch noises in public. I also appreciate that the bars are individually wrapped, because sharing feels noble until I remember I bought them for me. This is the kind of treat that works for Halloween candy bowls, gaming sessions, or any random Tuesday that needs rescuing. —Maya Collins

I bought the Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2) for “sharing,” and then mysteriously forgot where I put the bag. The one-of-a-kind peanut-buttery flavor and smooth chocolatey layer are dangerously easy to keep reaching for. I like that the 10.2 oz bags help keep everything fresh, which is great because I am apparently a very slow sharer. These are perfect for holiday parties, Easter egg hunts, or just standing in the kitchen pretending I’m not having dessert before dinner. —Olivia Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups Is Necessary

I think Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups are necessary because they bring together two flavors I already love in one satisfying bite. The mix of creamy peanut butter, chocolate, and that signature Butterfinger crunch gives me a treat that feels both familiar and exciting at the same time. It is the kind of snack that can instantly lift my mood when I need a little comfort or a quick reward.

For me, they are also necessary because they are more than just candy—they are a simple pleasure I can enjoy during a busy day. When I want something sweet without overthinking it, Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups give me that perfect balance of texture and taste. My snack time feels more complete when I have something this fun and indulgent.

I also like that they stand out from ordinary peanut butter cups. My experience is that they offer a little extra crunch and personality, which makes them feel special. That is why I would say Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups are necessary: they make a regular moment feel a lot more enjoyable.

My Buying Guides on Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups

What I Look for First

When I buy Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups, I first think about the flavor balance. I want that classic peanut butter cup taste, but with the crunchy, candy-like Butterfinger twist. For me, the best ones are the ones that keep the chocolate smooth while still giving me that unmistakable Butterfinger texture.

Check the Size and Portion

I always pay attention to the package size. Sometimes I want a single treat, and other times I want a shareable bag or box. If I’m buying for myself, I usually prefer smaller packs so I can enjoy them without overdoing it. If I’m stocking up for a party or movie night, I go for a larger bag.

Look at the Ingredients

I like to read the ingredient list before I buy. Since I’m choosing a candy, I expect sugar to be part of it, but I still check for ingredients I care about, like peanut content, chocolate type, and any allergens. Because these are peanut butter cups, I also make sure I’m comfortable with the peanut and dairy ingredients listed.

Consider the Texture

One thing I enjoy most is texture. A good Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cup should have a creamy center with a little crunch that makes it different from regular peanut butter cups. If I’m trying a new pack, I look for reviews that mention whether the candy is too hard, too soft, or just right.

Compare Price and Value

I always compare the price per ounce or per piece. Some packs look affordable at first, but the pieces may be smaller than I expect. I usually choose the option that gives me the best value without sacrificing taste. If there’s a seasonal sale, I like to grab extra.

Check Freshness and Storage

I prefer buying from stores or sellers with good turnover so the candy stays fresh. I also pay attention to the expiration date. Once I bring them home, I store them in a cool, dry place so the chocolate doesn’t melt or lose its texture.

Read Reviews Before Buying

I often check customer reviews to see what other people think about the flavor and consistency. Reviews help me figure out whether the candy tastes like a true Butterfinger treat or if it’s just another peanut butter cup with a different label. I find this especially helpful when buying online.

My Final Buying Tip

For me, the best Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups are the ones that deliver both familiar peanut butter cup comfort and that signature Butterfinger crunch. I buy them when I want something sweet, a little different, and easy to enjoy. If I’m unsure, I start with a smaller pack first and decide if I want to buy more later.

Final Thoughts

I think Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups are a fun twist on a classic candy combination, bringing together crunchy, peanut buttery, and chocolatey flavors in a way that feels indulgent and satisfying. My takeaway is that they’re a great choice when I want something familiar but with a little extra texture and sweetness. Overall, I’d say they’re a tasty treat for anyone who enjoys bold candy flavors and a nostalgic snack experience.

Author Profile

Avatar
Anthony Whitley
Anthony Whitley, a seasoned basketball trainer, created Hornets Central to answer the questions people are often too shy to ask about sports. Here, readers find clear, down to earth explanations, covering terms, rules, and overlooked details across multiple games all built around real curiosity and a love for learning the basics.

Welcome to Hornets Central, where your curiosity is always welcome.